Libertarian group calls on public to question federal dietary guidelines

07/19/2018 05:18 PM

By: Eva McKend

WASHINGTON-Should the American government get out of the business of giving dietary advice? For decades, the USDA and Health and Human Services has been telling us what the best foods are for our bodies but a new report suggests the government should just stay out of it.

Many of us may have grown up being told to eat our fruits and veggies but one clinical biochemist warns it was bad nutrition advice from the federal government that has long put our health out of whack.

“Ever since 1977 when the American government through the Senate Committee told us to stop eating fat and start eating carbohydrates, we know now that was bad advice,” said Terence Kealey, Cato Institute Senior Fellow.

Terence Kealey with the libertarian Cato Institute says there is a reason the now disbanded Select Committee on Nutrition and Human Needs issued those guidelines.

“There was a real epidemic of heart attacks. In 1977, a third of all deaths in this country were caused by heart attacks, twice as many people were dying from heart attacks as from cancer. They believed that it was possibly due to the consumption of too much saturated fat, too many fats from meats and animals,” said Kealey.

Kealey argues this all had dire consequences.

“The increase in carbohydrates consumption in this country caused almost immediately the increase in obesity and the increase in Type 2 diabetes,” said Kealey.

According to decades of his research, the government is too influenced by corporate interests to continue being involved in telling the American public what foods to eat and what to avoid.

“There is a tension between the needs of agriculture and the needs of health. If the farmers had their way, we’d all sit down having 17,000 calories for breakfast because of course it would mean that they have earned all of this money selling their food,” said Kealey.

The USDA/DHS guidelines are issued every five years. At nearly 150 pages, many aspects of it are not very controversial including limiting calories from added sugars and saturated fats and reducing sodium intake. Kealey wants Congress to direct the agencies to stop issuing the guidelines but if they stop doing it, who should?

“There are dozens of medical schools, Departments of Nutrition and other really authoritative bodies in this country that can and should give dietary advice and we should leave it to a free market of ideas,” said Kealey.

We reached out to the USDA and HHS about Kealey’s research. They did not comment on his work specifically but the USDA pointed out that Congress mandates the agencies publish these guidelines and they defended them, telling us the guidelines can help to improve the health of Americans by encouraging healthy choices.

https://www.cato.org/publications/policy-analysis/why-does-federal-government-issue-damaging-dietary-guidelines-lessons

3 Comments

Comments

  • Cumberland Gap wrote on July 20, 2018 11:20 AM :

    The Libertarians are not pragmatic and very unrealistic living in a world of fantasy, like the leftist socialists. We currently have a free market of ideas with hundreds of sellers of easy pills, flash techniques, methods, and secret formulas to get thin and young again. You see it all the time on your social media and email, a never ending free market of solicitation how to be healthy. The Libertarians won’t tell you those “free market” sellers they like to promote are more motivated by their profit than your health outcomes. The free market idea providers often get it consistently wrong and are not God as the Libertarians like to mislead you like they are.

  • Cindy Sullivan, MS, RD, LD wrote on July 20, 2018 03:03 PM :

    The problem with people gaining weight and developing Type 2 diabetes is more about the free market than we think. How many people drink sweetened beverages that are promoted by the free market. More money is spent on advertising sugar laden foods than any other food group in the healthy range of choices. Keep in mind that free markets promote I phones, computers, and several other technologies that promote making our lives easier. That adds up to less activity… I have been in the business of nutrition for over 30 years and I have decided that there is no one way to stay healthy! The Government gives guidelines, not rules and some government programs have even improved the health of our young people. My vote is to get the free market out of it and get back to eating as much basic foods as possible. Get a little more activity and use some common sense!

  • Cindy Sullivan, MS, RD, LD wrote on July 20, 2018 03:03 PM :

    The problem with people gaining weight and developing Type 2 diabetes is more about the free market than we think. How many people drink sweetened beverages that are promoted by the free market. More money is spent on advertising sugar laden foods than any other food group in the healthy range of choices. Keep in mind that free markets promote I phones, computers, and several other technologies that promote making our lives easier. That adds up to less activity… I have been in the business of nutrition for over 30 years and I have decided that there is no one way to stay healthy! The Government gives guidelines, not rules and some government programs have even improved the health of our young people. My vote is to get the free market out of it and get back to eating as much basic foods as possible. Get a little more activity and use some common sense!

What do you have to say?





SUBSCRIBE NOW

Subscribe to email updates.

Subscribe and get the latest political intelligence delivered to your inbox.

TWEETS ABOUT KY POLITICS